John & Peter’s is the oldest continually owned music club in the USA and it’s right here in New Hope, PA. They have live entertainment everyday of the year and twice on Saturday and Sundays. Over the years artists many artists including; MARTIN MULL, PENN & TELLER , JOHN SEBASTIAN, GEORGE THOROGOOD, COUNTRY JOE MCDONALD, NEW RIDERS OF THE PURPLE SAGE, MARY CHAPIN CARPENTER, RICHIE SAMBORA, JOHN HAMMOND, NORAH JONES, IRON BUTTERFLY, BADFINGER, ORLEANS, TINY TIM, and SLIM PICKINS (from Dallas, Texas) have played this tiny venue either on the way up or the way down but they played here.
But Donna and I didn’t go for the music, we went for the burgers. Robbie had recommended J&P last weekend when we were on our Memorial Day Weekend Best in Bucks Burger Search but we didn’t make it. We made it tonight and it was a good recommendation.
To start we went for the Pork Wings. Four weeks ago I had never heard of pork wings in my 50+ years and now two times this month. We ran into them the first time at Big Bob’s BBQ and they were very tasty so we had to try them again. These wings were coated in apple cinnamon glaze and tasted more like pulled pork than the “mini-ham” wings we had at Big Bob’s. These were equally large and moist as Big Bob’s. One surprise was that the Apple and Cinnamon glaze did not penetrate the pork flesh but remained on the surface. That was a little disappointing for the first bite until I realized the existing taste was a great pulled pork taste. The huge size to the wings made this appetizer very filling.
Donna decided to go for the Cheesesteak for her main. That came with Sauteed Onions and Provolone Cheese with a side of Tater Tots. This classic sandwich is still Number 3 on our Sandwich Survey (shameless plug for taking the Sandwich Survey, if you haven’t taken it yet, take it now.) Donna’s sandwich was full of tender, moist beef covered in gooey cheese and caramelized onions. Very tasty. The Tater Tots were truly bite sized, crispy on the outside with a good potato taste on the inside.
There is only one burger on the menu and it comes standard with lettuce, red onions, tomato slices, pickles and potato chips. To customize your burger, John & Peter’s offers 6 Cheese Options; cheddar, Swiss, mozza, goat, blue cheese and pepper jack plus they also offer jalapenos, saute onions, saute peppers, salsa, mushrooms, roasted peppers and bacon. I got mine with Swiss Cheese, Mushrooms and Bacon. My first impression was the amount of bacon on the burger-5 slices. After I assembled the burger, it was huge. The first bite made me feel like Guy Fieri from the Food Network. I had to cut the burger in half to make it managable. In doing so I lost control of the mushrooms which squirted out onto the potato chips. No biggie but if they cooked the muchroom covered in cheese rather than place them on top of the cheese they may have stayed in the burger. The burger was very moist and I ended using three large napkins. The burger was cooked Medium Rare, becoming the first burger we reviewed being pink in the middle. The biggest taste of this burger was the strong bacon taste and the actual ground beef taste. Another first as the fix’ins had overcome the meat taste in other reviewed burgers on the first couple of bites. The moist perfectly cooked 8 oz of ground beef, the amount of bacon, cheese options and fresh veggie options makes it one of the Best Burgers in Bucks. Check out the other Best of Bucks- Burgers here.
It’s fun taking pictures of food in restaurants, you get all kinds of comments but at John & Peter’s, I got to meet Erik and his wife, Lisa and their friend at the bar and Dan and his girlfriend at the next table. Eric recommended the Pork Wings. Dan recommended the Catfish Po’Boy which came with homemade Remoulade Sauce which he had just finished.
Shout out to our wait staff Patti and ”Pumpkin”. “Pumpkin” was telling us The Raven is opening up soon under new management so we will be reporting from there soon. The Raven used to be Donna and my favourite upscale restaurant in New Hope.
John & Peter’s 96 South Main Street, New Hope, PA, 18938 215-862-5981